Help
Arrow
Or

Sylvesters Pizza

339 High Street, Preston
Italian Pizza Gluten Free Dessert Ice Cream Salad
5:00pm - 10:15pm
5:00pm - 10:15pm
Min. delivery: $20.00 + Delivery Fee
Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40 Free item over $35 Free item over $35 Free item over $40 Free item over $40 Free item over $45 Free item over $45 Free item over $60 Free item over $60 Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Meal Deals
Arrow

Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35 Free item over $35

Receive FREE 1 small Margherita worth $8 when you spend over $35.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40 Free item over $40

Receive FREE garlic bread when you spend over $40.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45 Free item over $45

Receive FREE 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90 when you spend over $45.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60 Free item over $60

Receive FREE 1 large Margherita worth $14 when you spend over $60.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Restaurant Accepts Visa Restaurant Accepts Mastercard Restaurant Accepts American Express Restaurant Accepts PayPal Restaurant Accepts Cash
Order for later
read reviews
  • Star Rating

Deals

Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35

Free 1 small Margherita worth $8

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40

Free garlic bread

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45

Free 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60

Free 1 large Margherita worth $14

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Located in downtown Preston on High Street, Sylvester's Pizza is well known for its authentic Italian food, complete with delicious deserts. Friendly service combined with excellent menu choices make Sylvester's Pizza a very popular restaurant. The pizzeria offers several different pizza choices including Americana, Seafood, and Hawaiian. Calzones and salads are also offered to complete the main course. For desert, Gelato or Nuttella Pizza are popular choices. They help to bring authentic Italian dishes to the table at reasonable prices

Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Page 1 of 16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next

1509 Sylvesters Pizza Reviews

  • -
    2160 Pts
    - PRESTON - June 2018
  • Excellent. Pizzas were delicious and delivered on time. Have used Sylvester's a number of times for our group - and each time have had people comment on how good the pizza's are!
  • -
    75 Pts
    - PRESTON - June 2018
  • -
    2160 Pts
    - PRESTON - June 2018
  • -
    205 Pts
    - KINGSBURY - June 2018
  • -
    100 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - June 2018
  • Always fantastic pizza!!!
  • -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - June 2018
  • Speed and value great. Customer service great. Actual pizzas are ok.
  • -
    35 Pts
    - June 2018
  • -
    1940 Pts
    - THORNBURY - June 2018
  • Simply the Best !!
  • -
    4350 Pts
    - PRESTON - May 2018
  • best pizzas in the northern suburbs hands down. And i have tried most! however the delivery price stings.. worth it at the end of the day though.
  • -
    1940 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - May 2018
  • -
    2160 Pts
    - PRESTON - May 2018
  • Thumps up A+++++
  • -
    40 Pts
    - KINGSBURY - May 2018
  • Best Pizza in the northern suburbs!
  • -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - May 2018
  • -
    2545 Pts
    - COBURG - May 2018
  • No issues here great A+++++
  • -
    205 Pts
    - KINGSBURY - May 2018
  • I must say if you really want a good traditional pizza this is the place. I’ve been ordering hear for a while now and it’s very consistent 👍
  • -
    1095 Pts
    - NORTHCOTE - May 2018
  • Always great pizza!
  • -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - May 2018
  • Arrived within a few mins of when they said it would.. was definitely worth it.. I have a new fav!!!
  • -
    500 Pts
    - THORNBURY - May 2018
  • -
    2160 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - April 2018
  • Yummy and reasonably priced
  • -
    4350 Pts
    - PRESTON - April 2018
  • -
    140 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - April 2018
  • -
    100 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - April 2018
  • -
    150 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - April 2018
  • -
    105 Pts
    - April 2018
  • chips good,. Margherita bit average.
  • -
    3255 Pts
    - THORNBURY - April 2018
  • Best Pizza in the Northern Suburbs!
  • -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - April 2018
  • Best Pizza Parlour in Melbourne!
  • -
    4350 Pts
    - PRESTON - April 2018
  • never ordering again... late and soggy pizza. wasted my money. Terrible!!!
  • -
    215 Pts
    - PRESTON - April 2018
  • -
    2545 Pts
    - COBURG - April 2018
  • -
    1940 Pts
    - THORNBURY - April 2018
  • -
    1940 Pts
    - THORNBURY - March 2018
  • Fast, Efficient Delivery with a smile. Pizza and Garlic Bread hot, fresh and tasty!
  • -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - March 2018
NAomi - HADFIELD
  • -
    455 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - March 2018
  • -
    75 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - March 2018
  • -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - March 2018
  • Delivery came well before expected time, Good Aussie style pizza, not a fan of the European fancy thin based try hards :)
  • -
    210 Pts
    - PRESTON - March 2018
  • -
    1320 Pts
    - PRESTON - March 2018
  • Fast delivery great pizza.
  • -
    45 Pts
    - March 2018
  • -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - March 2018
  • -
    140 Pts
    - March 2018
  • Maninder -
    100 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - March 2018
  • Fast Delivery, Meal was delivered hot and prepared with care.
  • Michael -
    210 Pts
    - PRESTON - March 2018
  • Geoff -
    2545 Pts
    - COBURG - March 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - March 2018
  • Rob -
    1320 Pts
    - PRESTON - March 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - February 2018
  • Best Pizza Place in Melbourne !
  • Alison -
    4350 Pts
    - PRESTON - February 2018
  • Geoff -
    2545 Pts
    - COBURG - February 2018
  • Harsha -
    85 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - February 2018
  • Amii -
    1235 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - February 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - February 2018
  • Geoff -
    2545 Pts
    - COBURG - February 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - February 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - February 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • Awesome! Will buy again.
  • Pritpal -
    215 Pts
    - PRESTON - January 2018
  • Rob -
    1320 Pts
    - PRESTON - January 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • Amazing quality of food, quick service and good value. Very happy.
  • Michael -
    35 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - January 2018
  • Best Pizza in the Northern Suburbs!
  • Vance -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - January 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • NIck -
    1325 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - January 2018
  • Simply the best pizza in Melbourne and always has been!
  • Alison -
    4350 Pts
    - PRESTON - January 2018
  • Mihir -
    815 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - January 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • One of the best pizzas i have ever had, VEGGIE SUPREME EVERYTIME XXXXX
  • Lloyd -
    225 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - January 2018
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • Forgot drink again!!!!!
  • Jason -
    2490 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • I have ordered thousands of pizzas over my life but this stores pizzas are truly amazing.

    THE BEST EVER BY FAR
  • Lloyd -
    225 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - January 2018
  • Kellee -
    180 Pts
    - PRESTON - January 2018
  • As always prompt & hot delivery, meat lovers pizza recommended!!
  • Jo -
    505 Pts
    - HEIDELBERG WEST - January 2018
  • Hot pizza was mild. The Hawaiin was meh.
  • Simon -
    925 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • George -
    650 Pts
    - THORNBURY - December 2017
  • Phillip -
    1240 Pts
    - COBURG - December 2017
  • Alex -
    2160 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • Pretty average nutella pizza but the margherita was good
  • Emily -
    60 Pts
    - NORTHCOTE - December 2017
  • Helen -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • Ben -
    380 Pts
    - HEIDELBERG WEST - December 2017
  • The pizzas were good, but the delivery person asked us if we had paid, which of course we did when we paid through the app. And the receipt showed we had paid. It felt like he was going to ask us for more money. Ruined the experience, I've never had trouble with Sylvester's before.
  • Domenic -
    765 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - December 2017
  • Mihir -
    815 Pts
    - December 2017
  • Kellee -
    180 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • navdeep -
    45 Pts
    - December 2017
  • Yatin -
    30 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - December 2017
  • I don't remember if this was any good because I was drunk, but I'm sure it was fine
  • John -
    2315 Pts
    - Thornbury - December 2017
  • FRamk -
    105 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • Rob -
    1320 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • Helen -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • Helen -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - December 2017
  • Helen -
    5700 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • Excellent!
  • Marcus -
    505 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • Great Food and Service every time!
  • Vance -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - December 2017
  • Words cannot describe how GOOD these pizzas are! Base was both crunchy and soft, huge amount of evenly spread toppings! Certainly got the “WOW” from all of us! Thankyou sylvesters! Will definitely be ordering from here again!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND F
  • Jess -
    425 Pts
    - COBURG - December 2017
  • Ordered four pizzas, 2 were fine, up to the usual standards and 2 were over cooked, more care and attention required
  • NIck -
    1325 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - December 2017
  • Anastasia -
    430 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - November 2017
  • as usual. Perfect!!
  • Joe -
    450 Pts
    - THORNBURY - November 2017
  • Gerald -
    3220 Pts
    - THORNBURY - November 2017
  • Pizza and service outstanding!
  • Vance -
    705 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - November 2017
  • Love it!
  • Pritpal -
    215 Pts
    - PRESTON - November 2017
  • Mihir -
    815 Pts
    - November 2017
Page 1 of 16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
End of Reviews
This restaurant is currently closed, but you can still place your order now for later when it opens.
Why order online?

Find more
restaurants
in your area

Sign in to order on EatNow

Or

Forgot password?

New to EatNow? Continue on
Menulog instead

Menulog

Looks like you’re new
to EatNow

As EatNow is joining Menulog,
to create a new account, visit Menulog.

Continue on Menulog

Have an EatNow account?
Sign in here