Arrow
Or

Sylvesters Pizza - Preston

339 High Street, Preston
Italian Pizza Gluten Free Dessert Ice Cream Salad
5:00pm - 10:15pm
5:00pm - 10:15pm
Min. delivery: $20.00 + Delivery Fee
Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40 Free item over $35 Free item over $35 Free item over $40 Free item over $40 Free item over $45 Free item over $45 Free item over $60 Free item over $60 Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Meal Deals
Arrow

Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35 Free item over $35

Receive FREE 1 small Margherita worth $8 when you spend over $35.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40 Free item over $40

Receive FREE garlic bread when you spend over $40.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45 Free item over $45

Receive FREE 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90 when you spend over $45.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60 Free item over $60

Receive FREE 1 large Margherita worth $14 when you spend over $60.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Restaurant Accepts Visa Restaurant Accepts Mastercard Restaurant Accepts American Express Restaurant Accepts PayPal Restaurant Accepts Cash
Order for later
read reviews
  • Star Rating

Deals

Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35

Free 1 small Margherita worth $8

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40

Free garlic bread

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45

Free 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60

Free 1 large Margherita worth $14

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Located in downtown Preston on High Street, Sylvester's Pizza is well known for its authentic Italian food, complete with delicious deserts. Friendly service combined with excellent menu choices make Sylvester's Pizza a very popular restaurant. The pizzeria offers several different pizza choices including Americana, Seafood, and Hawaiian. Calzones and salads are also offered to complete the main course. For desert, Gelato or Nuttella Pizza are popular choices. They help to bring authentic Italian dishes to the table at reasonable prices

Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Page 1 of 18
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next

1752 Sylvesters Pizza Reviews

  • Ordered right on 5pm, took over an hour to arrive. They forgot to deliver a drink ordered, and one pizza was burnt, along with garlic bread overcooked. Never had problems before, believe there are new owners. Never again..
  • - - PRESTON - September 2019
  • Got a super supreme nice pizza! But had No pineapple it should have. I paid for that pineapple 🍍. Next time hope i get pineapple 🍍 cost 24.30
  • - - RESERVOIR - August 2019
  • Very tasty pizzas
  • - - THORNBURY - August 2019
  • - - PRESTON - August 2019
  • My last two orders were awful. Our pizzas were filled with black strands of hair and included ingredients we didn't want added. When I called the store to inform them of this, the person who answered didn't seem to understand English and just hung up on me. This is really sad as all our other previous orders we very good.
  • - - ALPHINGTON - August 2019
  • - - COBURG - August 2019
  • - - PRESTON WEST - August 2019
  • Creepy and dishonest. Did not deliver paid in advance pizza, but insisted they had. Delivery man invented a story about a tall man with an earring who was waiting at my front door and went to the gate to get the pizza from him, before he entered the yard! Refused to replace missing order, am now pursuing refund. Who needs this? Go elsewhere. Deserve no stars, but had to select one star to submit review.
  • - - RESERVOIR - July 2019
  • - - PRESTON - July 2019
  • Love the super supreme! Always fresh and De Lish can’t fault.👍
  • - - RESERVOIR - July 2019
  • Pizza was nice, good sizes, would definitely order again. Delivery was slow, but it was at peak times, so very understandable.

    Star off for forgetting our free garlic bread though, as we'd ordered $42 worth of food but got nothing but what we ordered. Not the biggest deal, but we were still disappointed.
  • - - NORTHCOTE - July 2019
  • Yummy pizza delivered on time
  • - - THORNBURY - July 2019
  • Great pizzas 🍕 crusty base not soggy.
    Sat night was busy said hour and was hour
  • - - RESERVOIR - July 2019
  • - - PRESTON - July 2019
  • Delivered on time and the pizza was perfect
  • - - THORNBURY - July 2019
  • - - COBURG - July 2019
  • The driver got the address wrong and had to call to ask where the food was to be delivered. He didn't understand what Unit 1, Number 7 XXXXXX Street meant. The food finally arrived.
  • - - KINGSBURY - July 2019
  • Very nice pizza very clean place very fresh ingredients keep it up
  • - - RESERVOIR - July 2019
  • Perfect as always
  • - - PRESTON - July 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • - - PRESTON - July 2019
  • - - June 2019
  • - - HEIDELBERG WEST - June 2019
  • Best Pizza in Preston!
  • - - PRESTON - June 2019
  • Stated it would arrive at 7:50 didn’t arrive until 8:30. But at least the pizza was still hot and very delicious
  • - - THORNBURY - June 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • - - PRESTON - June 2019
  • Best regular pizza joint around. Nicks special with pineapple is the bizness. Chocolate mousse is awesome too.
  • - - PRESTON - June 2019
  • Delivered on time and the pizza was perfect
  • - - THORNBURY - June 2019
  • - - THORNBURY - June 2019
  • Delivered on time and the pizza was perfect
  • - - THORNBURY - June 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • - - PRESTON - June 2019
  • Scrumptious as always
    Best pizza in Victoria!
    Fast delivery great prices what more can anybody ask for?
    Alison from PRESTON
  • - - PRESTON - May 2019
  • - - THORNBURY - May 2019
  • - - THORNBURY - May 2019
  • - - RESERVOIR - May 2019
  • - - HEIDELBERG WEST - May 2019
  • Always Superb
    Never disappoints
    Alison and John
  • - - PRESTON - May 2019
  • - - THORNBURY - May 2019
  • Pizza was very good but delivery took over an hour and a half. Very slow and gave pathetic excuses.
  • - - RESERVOIR - May 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • - - PRESTON - May 2019
  • Fast delivery and great pizza
  • - - COBURG - April 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - April 2019
  • Alison - - PRESTON - April 2019
  • Tseb azzip
  • RIck - - RESERVOIR - April 2019
  • Alex - - PRESTON - April 2019
  • Best Pizza Ever!
  • Vance - - RESERVOIR - April 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi - - PRESTON - April 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - March 2019
  • Alex - - PRESTON - March 2019
  • matthew - - RESERVOIR - March 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - March 2019
  • Anthony - - March 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi - - PRESTON - March 2019
  • Simply the best!!!!
  • Alison - - PRESTON - March 2019
  • ELaine - - RESERVOIR - March 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - March 2019
  • Still the best Pizzas around. No contest.
  • Pat - - COBURG NORTH - March 2019
  • ELaine - - RESERVOIR - February 2019
  • Best !!!!!!!!!!
  • George - - NORTHCOTE - February 2019
  • Best Pizza in town! Great value for money, tasty and fresh!
  • Vance - - RESERVOIR - February 2019
  • roberta - - PRESTON WEST - February 2019
  • ELaine - - RESERVOIR - February 2019
  • Alison - - PRESTON - February 2019
  • Maninder - - RESERVOIR - February 2019
  • We order from here all the time. Mimo special is amazing!!! Always speedy friendly delivery. We can’t move house because we love them so much!
  • George - - NORTHCOTE - February 2019
  • Neeraj - - February 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - February 2019
  • Peter - - IVANHOE - February 2019
  • I got gastro from this place and will never eat from here again
  • Niko - - PRESTON - February 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - January 2019
  • Maninder - - RESERVOIR - January 2019
  • Enjoy
  • Anna - - COBURG - January 2019
  • Peter - - IVANHOE - January 2019
  • Juanita - - THORNBURY - January 2019
  • Peter - - IVANHOE - January 2019
  • 👍💕🍕
  • George - - NORTHCOTE - January 2019
  • best pizza and calzone. every time.
    plenty of topping.
  • Pat - - COBURG NORTH - January 2019
  • Always the best!!
  • Alex - - PRESTON - January 2019
  • Maninder - - RESERVOIR - January 2019
  • wayne - - RESERVOIR - January 2019
  • Nice , enjoy
  • Anna - - COBURG - January 2019
  • Love you guys x
  • George - - NORTHCOTE - January 2019
  • Juanita - - THORNBURY - January 2019
  • wayne - - RESERVOIR - January 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - January 2019
  • Juanita - - THORNBURY - January 2019
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi - - PRESTON - January 2019
  • Awesome Pizza!!! A must try!
  • Vance - - RESERVOIR - January 2019
  • Peter - - IVANHOE - January 2019
  • Helen - - PRESTON - January 2019
  • Best pizza in Melbourne can’t be beaten
    Thanks folks keep up the good work cos you never disappoint!
    Alison
  • Alison - - PRESTON - January 2019
  • Always amazing
  • George - - NORTHCOTE - January 2019
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - December 2018
  • Peter - - IVANHOE - December 2018
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi - - PRESTON - December 2018
  • Alex - - PRESTON - December 2018
  • Helen - - PRESTON - December 2018
  • Milana - - RESERVOIR - December 2018
  • Gerald - - THORNBURY - December 2018
  • Alex - - PRESTON - December 2018
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi - - PRESTON - December 2018
Page 1 of 18
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
End of Reviews
This restaurant is currently closed, but you can still place your order now for later when it opens.
Why order online?

Find more
restaurants
in your area