Help
Arrow
Or

Sylvesters Pizza

339 High Street, Preston
Italian Pizza Gluten Free Dessert Ice Cream Salad
5:00pm - 9:50pm
5:00pm - 9:50pm
Min. delivery: $20.00 + Delivery Fee
Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40 Free item over $35 Free item over $35 Free item over $40 Free item over $40 Free item over $45 Free item over $45 Free item over $60 Free item over $60 Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Meal Deals
Arrow

Free delivery over $40 Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35 Free item over $35

Receive FREE 1 small Margherita worth $8 when you spend over $35.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40 Free item over $40

Receive FREE garlic bread when you spend over $40.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45 Free item over $45

Receive FREE 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90 when you spend over $45.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60 Free item over $60

Receive FREE 1 large Margherita worth $14 when you spend over $60.

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Restaurant Accepts Visa Restaurant Accepts Mastercard Restaurant Accepts American Express Restaurant Accepts PayPal Restaurant Accepts Cash
Order for later
read reviews
  • Star Rating

Deals

Free delivery over $40

Get your order delivered free when you spend over $40

The order total (including other discounts, not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $35

Free 1 small Margherita worth $8

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $35.

Free item over $40

Free garlic bread

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $40.

Free item over $45

Free 1 medium Margherita worth $11.90

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $45.

Free item over $60

Free 1 large Margherita worth $14

Not valid with any other promotion or special, the order total (not including delivery fee) must be over $60.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Sylvesters Pizza offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Delivery Specials’ section of the menu for more details.

Located in downtown Preston on High Street, Sylvester's Pizza is well known for its authentic Italian food, complete with delicious deserts. Friendly service combined with excellent menu choices make Sylvester's Pizza a very popular restaurant. The pizzeria offers several different pizza choices including Americana, Seafood, and Hawaiian. Calzones and salads are also offered to complete the main course. For desert, Gelato or Nuttella Pizza are popular choices. They help to bring authentic Italian dishes to the table at reasonable prices

Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Sunday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:50pm
Friday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 10:15pm
Page 1 of 15
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next

1408 Sylvesters Pizza Reviews

  • Forgot drink again!!!!!
  • -
    2235 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2018
  • I have ordered thousands of pizzas over my life but this stores pizzas are truly amazing.

    THE BEST EVER BY FAR
  • -
    160 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - January 2018
  • As always prompt & hot delivery, meat lovers pizza recommended!!
  • -
    495 Pts
    - HEIDELBERG WEST - January 2018
  • Hot pizza was mild. The Hawaiin was meh.
  • -
    865 Pts
    - PRESTON - December 2017
  • -
    970 Pts
    - COBURG - December 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • -
    280 Pts
    - HEIDELBERG WEST - December 2017
  • The pizzas were good, but the delivery person asked us if we had paid, which of course we did when we paid through the app. And the receipt showed we had paid. It felt like he was going to ask us for more money. Ruined the experience, I've never had trouble with Sylvester's before.
  • -
    655 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - December 2017
  • -
    745 Pts
    - December 2017
  • -
    45 Pts
    - December 2017
  • -
    30 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - December 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - December 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - December 2017
  • Great Food and Service every time!
  • -
    570 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - December 2017
  • Words cannot describe how GOOD these pizzas are! Base was both crunchy and soft, huge amount of evenly spread toppings! Certainly got the “WOW” from all of us! Thankyou sylvesters! Will definitely be ordering from here again!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND F
  • -
    385 Pts
    - COBURG - December 2017
  • Ordered four pizzas, 2 were fine, up to the usual standards and 2 were over cooked, more care and attention required
  • -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - December 2017
  • -
    390 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - November 2017
  • as usual. Perfect!!
  • -
    290 Pts
    - THORNBURY - November 2017
  • -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - November 2017
  • Pizza and service outstanding!
  • -
    570 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - November 2017
  • -
    745 Pts
    - November 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON - November 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - November 2017
  • -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - November 2017
  • -
    1710 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2017
  • All good
    But the vegi pizza has too much salt in it
  • -
    45 Pts
    - October 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • Great as always
  • -
    745 Pts
    - Reservoir - October 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • excellent service, beautiful Pizzas and super efficient, arrived well before the time approximation!! thank you
  • -
    50 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2017
  • Simply the Best Pizza in Victoria!
  • -
    3570 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2017
  • -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - October 2017
  • speedy delivery, very tasty pizza
  • -
    795 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - October 2017
  • Prompt & hot delivery, enjoyed the half'n'half seafood/Mimo special pizza,great value & would recommend to anyone !!
  • -
    495 Pts
    - HEIDELBERG WEST - October 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - October 2017
  • Delicious and reliable
  • -
    1210 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - October 2017
  • -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • Delish! Our favourite takeaway pizza in the area
  • Monika -
    685 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2017
  • NIck -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - October 2017
  • Very happy with all aspects of service again last night. Speed of delivery, quality of pizza etc all great. Thank you
  • Lincoln -
    40 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • Vanessa -
    230 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2017
  • sam -
    795 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - October 2017
  • Pizza was delicious. Food arrived earlier than time indicated and piping hot
  • Lincoln -
    40 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - October 2017
  • thank you, first time use, excellent service and delicious pizzas, terrific value for money!
  • Michelle -
    50 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
  • Mihir -
    745 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - September 2017
  • Andrew -
    1710 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Best Pizza in Melbourne!
  • Vance -
    570 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - September 2017
  • Jagtar -
    35 Pts
    - KINGSBURY - September 2017
  • Delicious and fresh every time!
  • Chris -
    215 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • On time, hot pizza
  • NIck -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
  • Fab pizza shop with yummy pizzas. Lots of topping and a great range, all the standard & a few unusual ones like the Satay Chicken or the Peri Peri. Can get busy as it's the best & us locals know it.
  • Craig -
    25 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - September 2017
  • Mihir -
    745 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
Mel
  • Best pizza in the area
  • Mel -
    600 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
  • NIck -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - September 2017
  • Alison -
    3570 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Alex -
    1785 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
  • Helen -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2017
  • Benjamin -
    315 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Delivered well, pizzas were hot. Ordered two pizzas no cheese so a bit odd to get a free pizza with cheese on? Pizza could do with seasoning as the mushrooms are pretty tasteless. Otherwise was good.
  • Rach -
    25 Pts
    - PRESTON - September 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • Anastasia -
    390 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - August 2017
  • I've noticed the pizzas are starting to be overcooked. Cheese should just be melted, not burnt.
  • Domenic -
    655 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - August 2017
  • Helen -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - August 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • david -
    2305 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • Aditya -
    190 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi -
    1665 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Always delicious with plenty of toppings and delivered fast
  • Kerryann -
    155 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Abby -
    300 Pts
    - August 2017
  • NIck -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - August 2017
  • SUe -
    105 Pts
    - NORTHCOTE - August 2017
  • Emma -
    3880 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - August 2017
  • Great Pizzas!!!
  • Nitin -
    115 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Delicious but a wee bit soggy. First time ever. Mushrooms made the dough wet. please dry them off a bit first.
    Thanks
  • Alison -
    3570 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Mihir -
    745 Pts
    - August 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • Awesome pizzas.... one of my favourites. Well priced.....delivery time could be better.
  • Chris -
    170 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - August 2017
  • NeTTy -
    1770 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - August 2017
  • Helen -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON SOUTH - August 2017
  • Daniel -
    1405 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Lilia -
    295 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • Helen -
    5045 Pts
    - PRESTON - August 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - August 2017
  • Jeff -
    145 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - August 2017
  • Great pizza, arrived intact
  • Nick -
    175 Pts
    - THORNBURY - July 2017
  • Monica -
    35 Pts
    - July 2017
  • NIck -
    1245 Pts
    - COBURG NORTH - July 2017
  • Perfect as Usual
    My Regards to the great Pizza Makers!
  • Alison -
    3570 Pts
    - PRESTON - July 2017
  • NeTTy -
    1770 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - July 2017
  • Gerald -
    2525 Pts
    - THORNBURY - July 2017
Page 1 of 15
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
End of Reviews
This restaurant is currently closed, but you can still place your order now for later when it opens.
Why order online?

Find more
restaurants
in your area

Sign in to order on EatNow

Or

Forgot password?

EatNow is joining Menulog

Menulog Find food on Menulog