Help
Arrow
Or

Plain Jane Pizza and Shakes

14D / 18 Gilbert Road, Preston
Pizza Italian
5:00pm - 8:30pm
5:00pm - 8:45pm
Min. delivery: $15.00 Delivery Fee: $4.00
10% off First Time Orders 10% off 1st time Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Meal Deals
Arrow

10% off First Time Orders 10% off First Time Orders

10% off your first order with this restaurant.

Not valid with any other promotion or special.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Plain Jane Pizza and Shakes offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Special Deals’ section of the menu for more details.

Restaurant Accepts Visa Restaurant Accepts Mastercard Restaurant Accepts American Express Restaurant Accepts PayPal Restaurant Accepts Cash
Order for later
read reviews
  • Star Rating

Deals

10% off First Time Orders

10% off your first order with this restaurant.

Not valid with any other promotion or special.

Restaurant Specials or Meal Deals

Plain Jane Pizza and Shakes offers meal deals or specials. See the ‘Special Deals’ section of the menu for more details.

Sunday 5:00pm to 8:30pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 8:30pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 8:30pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:30pm
Friday 5:00pm to 9:30pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 9:30pm
Sunday 5:00pm to 8:45pm
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:00pm to 8:45pm
Wednesday 5:00pm to 8:45pm
Thursday 5:00pm to 9:45pm
Friday 5:00pm to 9:45pm
Saturday 5:00pm to 9:45pm

47 Plain Jane Pizza and Shakes Reviews

  • This is the second time we have eaten Plain Jane Pizza. I wasn’t convinced after our first experience and I’m still not. The margherita + mushrooms + pineapple was fine for our young son. “The Nacho” however, was barely edible. Very dry and tasteless, I had to coat it in tomato sauce in an attempt to rectify. Will not buy from there again. The pizzas did arrive when they said they would.
  • -
    45 Pts
    - PRESTON - November 2017
  • Very disappointed in their service. Ordered food at 6:50pm and was told that it would be delivered at 8:05 pm (this is on a Tuesday!) and the food didn't arrive until 8:40- took 1 hour and 50 minutes! The pizza was luke warm and there was very little pizza sauce on both pizzas- tasted like a smear of crushed tomatoes. Both pizzas were flavourless barely warm. The only reason I'm giving one star is for the milkshakes we ordered- both arrived chilled and were tasty. Aside from that I wouldn't order from here again. Improve your pizza sauce and time management!
  • -
    550 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - October 2017
  • -
    565 Pts
    - COBURG - October 2017
  • -
    60 Pts
    - COBURG - October 2017
  • -
    565 Pts
    - COBURG - October 2017
  • -
    565 Pts
    - COBURG - October 2017
  • Always fast & hot - my go to pizza night store
  • -
    265 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - August 2017
  • -
    60 Pts
    - COBURG - August 2017
  • Great milkshakes and Pizza's
  • -
    175 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - July 2017
  • -
    305 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - July 2017
  • -
    65 Pts
    - July 2017
  • they get 1 star for the milkshake which wasnt even the flavour that i ordered but it was still good, the pizza was inedible, chewy, disgusting crust and the toppings made me want to throw up. i couldnt even give it away to my housemates. absolutely appalling. i thought plain jane was just a bad name choice but it turns out that it rings true. more plain than the sahara desert.
  • -
    960 Pts
    - PRESTON - June 2017
  • Nice tasting pizzas but needs more topping to satisfy hunger!
  • -
    3840 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - June 2017
  • Love, love this place - always great pizzas and fast delivery! Our new fav pizza place!!!
  • -
    265 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - May 2017
  • -
    65 Pts
    - PRESTON - May 2017
  • Really tasty pizza.
  • -
    445 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - May 2017
  • Always fast & great tasting- love this joint!
  • -
    265 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - April 2017
  • Always ready on time, good pizza, excellent service :)
  • -
    45 Pts
    - April 2017
Adam - THORNBURY
  • best pizza in thornbury!
  • -
    1210 Pts
    - THORNBURY - March 2017
Benjamin
  • -
    3515 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - February 2017
  • Everything was amazing!
  • -
    335 Pts
    - FAIRFIELD - January 2017
  • Very tasty - one of the best crusts I have ever eaten. Pizzas were ready in time indicated and piping hot. Definitely going back.
  • -
    35 Pts
    - January 2017
  • Great Pizza, even better the next morning for breakfast!
  • -
    1465 Pts
    - THORNBURY - January 2017
  • -
    445 Pts
    - January 2017
  • -
    690 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - January 2017
  • Great tasting, perfectly balanced pizzas with toppings spread right to the edges.
  • -
    25 Pts
    - December 2016
  • Crust is a bit thick, but overall was good.
  • -
    35 Pts
    - December 2016
  • Decent
  • -
    1740 Pts
    - Reservoir - November 2016
  • -
    25 Pts
    - October 2016
  • Great! I just think you need more vegetarian items on the menu.
    Delivery lady was excellent.
  • -
    55 Pts
    - PRESTON WEST - October 2016
  • Great za, great service
  • -
    60 Pts
    - October 2016
  • Great pizza delivered on time.
  • -
    125 Pts
    - PRESTON - October 2016
  • The name is probably not apt as conjures up thoughts of tasteless which the pizza is far from. The gelato section is what prompted me to order as who can go past passion fruit? AAA I'll be back :)
  • -
    2920 Pts
    - NORTHCOTE - September 2016
  • The best pizza I've had in ages! I've found my pizza restaurant!
  • -
    1215 Pts
    - THORNBURY - September 2016
  • Location good. Quick but I didn't get my confirmation text. Pizza was ok. Not as good as other times we have eaten from here. The pizzas don't sit heavy like some other places. Will keep giving them a try
  • -
    1105 Pts
    - September 2016
  • First-timers, we had the Mediterranean which was really lovely, light and tasty. Recommend!
  • -
    45 Pts
    - September 2016
  • -
    860 Pts
    - August 2016
  • Gluten free base OK kind of pancake-ish flavour and texture.
    It was still tasty, with fresh toppings, not too much on it but the toppings slid off easily...
  • -
    325 Pts
    - BRUNSWICK - August 2016
  • -
    35 Pts
    - August 2016
  • Awesome. Fast. Great place
  • -
    820 Pts
    - COBURG - June 2016
  • Tegan -
    585 Pts
    - PRESTON - June 2016
  • Showell -
    1335 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - June 2016
  • Love!!! Yummy as!
  • Kate -
    430 Pts
    - NORTHCOTE - May 2016
  • average
  • Aaron -
    2295 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - May 2016
  • MICHELLE -
    35 Pts
    - RESERVOIR - May 2016
  • Yum, hot pizza, great delivery service.
  • Bianca -
    250 Pts
    - COBURG - May 2016
Kathi - PRESTON
  • Kathi -
    1635 Pts
    - PRESTON - May 2016
End of Reviews
This restaurant is currently closed, but you can still place your order now for later when it opens.
Why order online?

Find more
restaurants
in your area