Arrow
Or

Cagney's Pizza

Shop 4, 2 Overton Lea Blvd, Sydenham
Pizza Pasta
4:30pm - 10:00pm
4:30pm - 10:00pm
Min. delivery: $0.00 Delivery Fee: $5.00
Arrow
Restaurant Accepts Visa Restaurant Accepts Mastercard Restaurant Accepts American Express Restaurant Accepts PayPal Restaurant Accepts Cash
Order for later
read reviews
  • Star Rating
Sunday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Monday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Tuesday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Wednesday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Thursday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Friday 4:30pm to 11:00pm
Saturday 4:30pm to 11:00pm
Sunday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Monday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Tuesday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Wednesday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Thursday 4:30pm to 10:00pm
Friday 4:30pm to 11:00pm
Saturday 4:30pm to 11:00pm
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 Next

218 Cagney's Pizza Reviews

  • -
    125 Pts
    - January 2019
  • Great pizzas, reasonable priced, delivery was prompt, courteous driver.
  • -
    100 Pts
    - DELAHEY - January 2019
  • Pizza was hot and fresh. Delivery came 10mins earlier than estimated which was great.
  • -
    25 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - January 2019
  • good
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - January 2019
  • -
    125 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - December 2018
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - December 2018
  • Nice Italian icecream selections.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Really nice pasta meal.
    Just on the pricey side.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Enjoyable meal. Speed and ease in delivery.
  • -
    100 Pts
    - DELAHEY - December 2018
  • Icecream flavors weren't correct in delivery. Dessert icecream Scoops/Serve are small considering price.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Delivery time a little long for local pizza orders. Pizza can get bit soggy underneath at base. Delivery Receipt is usually put in box airhole then it blocks steam from releasing. Doesn't help pizza breathe while it sits in box as base isn't crisp.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Nice food, but gets expensive if you want to order 2 or more meal items with dessert, as prices are a bit high. Then add delivery cost.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Very quick delivery, polite well presented delivery guy.
  • -
    100 Pts
    - DELAHEY - December 2018
  • Great pizza
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2018
  • Very nice pizza.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • Pizza bit soggy. Delivery Receipt in pizza box airhole. By the time of delivery, steam created makes base soggy.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • -
    100 Pts
    - DELAHEY - November 2018
  • Good pizza and pasta, just expensive to enjoy often, as it adds up.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • pizza was great as always
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - November 2018
  • Good food, bit expensive.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • always good , quick delivery , nice and hot
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - November 2018
  • Tasty food. Good menu. Variety. Just a bit high prices.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • Dessert needs to be cheaper.
    Good selection though.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - November 2018
  • Pizza was ok. The lettuce in the souvlaki was brown..
    The delivery guy was very friendly.
  • -
    65 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - October 2018
  • good as always
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - October 2018
  • Dessert to be more price competitive. But nice food.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - October 2018
  • Nice food as always
  • -
    220 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - October 2018
  • Bailey's dessert wasn't served in proper sized container. Needs larger square container. Arrived squashed up and soggy.
    Also too expensive for quantity served.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - October 2018
  • Good pizza selection from menu.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - October 2018
  • Ordered family sized pizza with the lot.
    On time, tasty, friendly service
  • -
    55 Pts
    - October 2018
  • Poor quality, expensive, not more cagneys for us
  • -
    700 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - October 2018
  • Great pizza and came before time advised, friendly driver. Thanks!
  • -
    60 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - October 2018
  • -
    320 Pts
    - DELAHEY - October 2018
  • Pizza is delicious.
    It took an hour from the time we ordered to delivery ( Friday night so I guess they were very busy)
    It is overpriced and pizzas are small.
  • -
    25 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - September 2018
  • GOOD AS ALWAYS , QUICK DELIVERY , NICE AND HOT
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - September 2018
  • Fast delivery and super tasty pizza!
  • -
    25 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - September 2018
  • Good food
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - September 2018
  • always good
  • -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - September 2018
  • -
    345 Pts
    - September 2018
  • Great pizza and icecream.
  • -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - September 2018
  • always good
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - September 2018
  • always good
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • Nice Italian pizza.
  • Elli -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - August 2018
  • Lots if pizza choices.
  • Elli -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - August 2018
  • Food was ok ,it took an hour and they forgot my drink
  • Simon -
    25 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - August 2018
  • every order has been great
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • good as always , nice and hoit
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • good as always
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • so far always good , it always arrives hot , tastes great
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • Italian authentic.
  • Elli -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - August 2018
  • good pizza will order again
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • Great pizza
  • Elli -
    465 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - August 2018
  • good pizza will order again
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - August 2018
  • pizza was great , ordering again
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - July 2018
  • pizza was good , arrived hot , will order again
  • albert -
    1130 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - July 2018
  • Pizza was delivered before stated time. Lots of filling but olives were missing.
  • France -
    55 Pts
    - KEILOR LODGE - June 2018
  • Suma -
    40 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - May 2018
  • Jess -
    340 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - April 2018
  • Meal was delicious and arrived in half the time we expected
  • Andrea -
    800 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - April 2018
  • Food is great that is why i keep ordering the same food. love it
  • Jennifer -
    45 Pts
    - DELAHEY - April 2018
  • It was all well prepared, and very yummy. Thank you.
  • John -
    35 Pts
    - March 2018
  • * Always Great Pizzas *
  • Greg -
    95 Pts
    - TAYLORS HILL - March 2018
  • Marcus -
    1095 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - March 2018
  • Have been getting pizzas from Cagneys for years. Always great and service is good.
  • Julia -
    1035 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - February 2018
  • Marijo -
    250 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - February 2018
  • Marijo -
    250 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - January 2018
  • Easy to use. Speedy delivery.
  • Carmel -
    195 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - January 2018
  • NeTTy -
    1855 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - January 2018
  • Marijo -
    250 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2017
  • We ordered a pizza and chips tonight. Pizza was soggy & disgusting overall. Chips were very undercooked oily/soggy and the box was only 1/4 full. Last time was great, but this time is the last time.
  • Petru -
    2545 Pts
    - KEILOR DOWNS - December 2017
  • Food Cameron time and was fresh. Everyone loved the pizza!
  • Nicole -
    25 Pts
    - DELAHEY - December 2017
  • Standard of food is not very good sometimes obviously the chef doesn't taste the food he is preparing, specially during the week.The portions in plastic containers are only three quarters full !
  • Anna -
    2170 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - December 2017
  • Tiarne -
    25 Pts
    - December 2017
  • The spaghetti Bolognese was really nice, but the pizza was greasy and the topping was barely cooked and slide off the pizza base
  • Andrea -
    800 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - October 2017
  • It is usually very nice but this time we were not impressed. Our pizza had very little cheese and was barely cooked on top. Not to mention it was very soggy.
  • Nicole -
    45 Pts
    - HILLSIDE - October 2017
  • Cheesy garlic bread comes in a foil tray with normal slices of g. bread with cheese thrown on top which ends up being soggy.
  • Rachel -
    915 Pts
    - October 2017
  • Delivered on time and as ordered. Driver phoned a couple of times to ascertain our location as we are in a sopping centre and was very friendly. Pizza did not leave us craving water during the night so I would recommend them to any one.
  • Brendan -
    35 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - October 2017
  • Suzie -
    70 Pts
    - September 2017
  • I get cagneys pizza all the time. By fat the best pizza in the area. Their wood fire pizzas are the best and their chicken Parma is amazing. Fast delivery and never any dramas. Food always comes piping hot and fresh
  • Adam -
    1400 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - September 2017
  • REbecca -
    370 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - September 2017
  • Great quality. Deliciously good. Definately a return customer
  • Mary -
    500 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - August 2017
  • Rachelle -
    555 Pts
    - TAYLORS HILL - August 2017
  • ZOra -
    325 Pts
    - TAYLORS LAKES - August 2017
  • allycia -
    70 Pts
    - July 2017
  • Luv the pizza that's why we keep going back.
  • Mary-Anne -
    370 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - July 2017
  • bases weren't very crispy
  • Nick -
    975 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - July 2017
  • Suzie -
    70 Pts
    - July 2017
  • Pizza's are still the best, but for the 1st time ever I was missing a pizza in my home delivery.
  • Rachelle -
    555 Pts
    - TAYLORS HILL - July 2017
  • yummy as and just enough food :)
  • Susan -
    630 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - June 2017
  • A perfect cooked pizza base & ingredients don't fall off when u pick a slice up to eat.
  • Rachelle -
    555 Pts
    - TAYLORS HILL - June 2017
  • Simone -
    45 Pts
    - DELAHEY - June 2017
  • NeTTy -
    1855 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - June 2017
  • Decent not as good as they use to be
  • Pickel -
    1030 Pts
    - TAYLORS HILL - June 2017
  • Always great Pizza from Cagney's
  • Brendan -
    495 Pts
    - SYDENHAM - May 2017
  • Excellent in every way as usual!
  • steve -
    105 Pts
    - May 2017
  • That was faultless, thanks kindly 😁
  • NeTTy -
    1855 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - May 2017
  • Pizza was nice but crunched into 2 olive pips while eating the pizza
  • liam -
    865 Pts
    - DELAHEY - April 2017
  • justin -
    170 Pts
    - CAROLINE SPRINGS - April 2017
  • The normally amazing food unfortunately this has not been the case of late last time they burnt the bottom of the pizza it was charcoal called them and it was replaced they were apologetic all gud this time the pizza base was burnt again and it wasn't a little bit or I wouldn't have minded it was black on bottom they apologised sort of and replaced it with a pizza that was undercooked I top and burnt on bottom wouldn'ty leave a negative review only I don't feel that after last time returning it only to happen again is not good enough won't be taking the last one back I'm not hungry now and only would be happy with a refund as the rest of food was cold by time waited for another as I already wasted enough time but won't be ordering again after 4 years good bye cagneys
  • Ebony -
    55 Pts
    - April 2017
  • Large Parma - Good value
    I'll be back!
  • Graeme -
    35 Pts
    - April 2017
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 Next
End of Reviews
This restaurant is currently closed, but you can still place your order now for later when it opens.
Why order online?

Find more
restaurants
in your area